Sep. 12th, 2023

I am already disgusted by what we're calling "AI," what is actually scraping the language and art of human invention, ignoring copyright, and filtering that through the poorly-compensated labor of exploited people in a process so detrimental it causes similar long-term psychological impacts to that seen in content-moderators, consuming huge quantities of energy in the process...

As if I didn't have enough reasons to dislike it as implemented, here's another one, from someone talking about trying to depict his visibly disabled body via image generators:

Tech is not neutral. It can't be. It is always the sum total of human decisions, priorities, and tradeoffs, deployed to meet certain ends and desires, and particularly capitalistic interests. AI is far from being an exception to the rule. And in this case, any desire for image generation models to be able to represent me is going to butt heads with another incentive: the desire to avoid shocking users with body horror.

Successive model retrainings have made rendering humans much more accurate, and tighter restrictions on prompts have made it much harder to generate body horror, even intentionally. As a consequence, non-normative bodies are also incredibly difficult to generate, even when the engine is fed hyperspecific prompts.

It's not just that the training sets simply don't have examples of people who look like me. It's that the system is now explicitly engineered to resist imagining me.

…Hey, is now a good a time to mention that in an effort to "create a welcoming and inclusive community for all users," the Midjourney Community Guidelines consider "deformed bodies" a form of gore, and thus forbidden?

Profile

the cosmolinguist

June 2025

S M T W T F S
1 2 3 45 6 7
8910 11 1213 14
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930     

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags